The Red Devils are fighting to keep their season alive after a 2-2 draw in the first leg, where Onana's mistakes proved costly.

Amorim raised eyebrows when he dropped Onana for United's Premier League clash against Newcastle United, opting for Altay Bayindir in a 4-1 defeat.

The move, Amorim explained, was to give Onana a mental break. "Sometimes you need to let a player disconnect," he said after the Newcastle game. "Andre will be back in training, ready for the next one. The mental aspect is as important as the physical."

Onana, who had stirred headlines by claiming United were "way better" than Lyon before the first leg, now faces a critical moment to prove himself.

The Cameroon international's exclusion from the Newcastle trip sparked debate, with Bayindir's performance failing to convince fans he's ready to claim the No. 1 spot.

Former United defender Wes Brown, a five-time Premier League winner, backed Onana's return. "He's the more experienced keeper," Brown told AOS in an exclusive interview. "Despite the errors in Lyon, he's had great games this season. He can put it right."

Brown also urged United's squad to rise to the occasion at home. "It's a massive game. They know the season's on the line. They've got to take their chances."

United's campaign has been plagued by inconsistency, with the Europa League their last hope for silverware. "The standard at United is challenging for trophies," Brown added. "They're nowhere near that level, but this is their chance to show they can deliver."

Recent updates from United's camp suggest Amorim is leaning toward reinstating Onana, with sources close to the club indicating the manager values his experience for high-stakes matches.

Posts on X reflect divided fan opinions, with some praising Amorim's bold call to bench Onana, while others demand his return to face Lyon's attacking threat.

The Red Devils must overcome a resilient Lyon side, who showed their quality in the first leg. With the tie finely balanced, Amorim's goalkeeper choice could define United's European fate.

Will Andre Onana play in Man Utd's Europa League quarter-final against Lyon?